French Coconut Pie – A Decadent Baked Coconut Pie Treat

From the first time I watched my grandmother crack eggs and sprinkle coconut into a big ceramic bowl, I knew French coconut pie would always have a special place in my kitchen. She made it for every Sunday dinner, served warm with sweet tea and a dollop of cream. Years later, while training as a chef and learning techniques from around the world, I still found myself craving that same golden, chewy custard. This pie became one of my signature desserts. It’s rich, yet refreshingly simple—just like she taught me. Over time, I tested dozens of versions, including famous ones like the coconut pie Paula Deen showcases or the classic baked coconut pie from Southern kitchens. The one I’m sharing here brings back those memories, combining that unmistakable flavor with updated tips to make it foolproof.

Whether you’re a fan of easy coconut pie or trying your hand at an authentic French coconut pie recipe, you’re about to meet your new favorite dessert.

Rich Custard Filling & Coconut Flavor

A coconut custard like no other

The beauty of a French coconut pie lies in its perfect filling—sweet, dense, slightly chewy, and golden on top. What makes this filling stand out is the simple balance of pantry staples. Eggs, sugar, melted butter, and a splash of vinegar (or buttermilk) come together to create that tender, custard-like center. Sweetened shredded coconut provides body and texture. In my version, I recommend sticking to sweetened coconut because it contributes both chew and sweetness without the need for extra sugar.

The contrast between the soft center and crisp top is part of what makes this easy coconut pie unforgettable. You’ll notice a slight crackle when slicing in, thanks to the sugar caramelizing during baking. For a smoother custard, let your eggs and butter come to room temperature before mixing.

If you’re the type who appreciates an indulgent dessert like apple crisp cheesecake, then you’ll love the satisfying custardy depth of this pie. It’s homemade comfort at its finest.

Coconut flavor that pops—without being artificial

Getting that distinct coconut flavor without making it taste fake is key. That’s why I combine pure vanilla extract with just half a teaspoon of coconut extract—it lifts the flavor without overpowering it. Using flaked coconut adds authentic texture and gently toasts during baking for even more flavor.

This filling is also adaptable. Want it more tropical? Add a teaspoon of pineapple juice or swap vinegar for buttermilk. Craving extra richness? A spoonful of sour cream does wonders for the body.

When you’re craving a nostalgic, buttery dessert that walks the line between pie and custard, few things rival a slice of French coconut pie. If you’re into richly textured, sweet

Print

The Perfect Pie Crust for Coconut Custard

Choosing or making the crust

The foundation of any French coconut pie recipe is a good crust—but here’s the best part: you don’t have to make it from scratch. While I love the flaky texture of a homemade crust, a store-bought 9-inch unbaked pie shell works perfectly for this dessert. The filling is rich enough that a simple crust balances it beautifully. If you do go homemade, chill your dough and roll it thin.

Using a preheated baking sheet under your pie pan can help crisp the bottom crust, avoiding that dreaded soggy layer. It’s a simple trick that makes a big difference when baking custard-style pies like this one. The method is the same whether you’re baking creme brulee-inspired dishes or a gooey coconut creation like this.

Baking tips for a flaky, golden crust

When you’re working with a rich, egg-based filling, it’s important to let the crust hold its own. One smart move: brush the edges with a bit of reserved egg white just before baking. This gives the outer crust a glossy finish and adds structure. Don’t parbake the crust—it bakes fully along with the filling in this baked coconut pie method.

Another tip? Tent the edges of your crust with foil or use a pie shield if it begins browning too fast. This allows the center to cook fully without burning the edges.

Whether you’re craving something fancy like pistachio raspberry cake or the homey charm of a French coconut pie, a well-baked crust ensures every bite has the perfect crunch-to-custard ratio.

Baking Time and Perfect Texture

Ideal baking time and doneness cues

The magic of French coconut pie happens in the oven. Bake your pie at 350°F (175°C) for about 45 to 55 minutes. By the time it’s done, the top should be golden and slightly puffed, with the center just set—think gently firm, not jiggly. You’ll know it’s ready when the filling no longer looks wet in the middle and a knife inserted comes out with moist crumbs, not liquid.

If the top begins to brown too quickly, loosely cover the pie with aluminum foil during the last 10 minutes of baking. This helps protect the coconut from over-toasting while allowing the custard to finish cooking. It’s a technique I also use when baking delicacies like lemon raspberry cookies that require precise browning.

Timing may vary slightly depending on your oven and whether you’re using a metal or ceramic pie dish. Keep an eye on it in the final minutes.

Serving temperature and texture experience

Let the pie cool completely before slicing—it needs that time to firm up and create its signature chewy custard texture. Serve it at room temperature for the classic experience, or slightly warm for an extra cozy bite.

Once cooled, the filling will settle into a rich, soft layer with that signature crackly top. The texture contrasts beautifully: soft custard, chewy coconut, and crisp crust. It’s this trifecta that makes French coconut pie so satisfying—and totally worth the wait.

For storage, this pie holds up well at room temperature for a couple of days if made without dairy. If you added buttermilk or sour cream, refrigerate it and enjoy cold or gently warmed. It’s just as comforting as a slice of French strawberry cake—but with a coconut twist.

Variations and Storage Tips for French Coconut Pie

Coconut pie variations to try

While the classic French coconut pie is already unforgettable, a few well-tested variations can bring new life to this traditional treat. One popular twist is the coconut pie Paula Deen version, which includes all-purpose flour and milk in the filling. The result? A slightly lighter texture with a more custard-like consistency that’s great for those who prefer a silkier bite.

Another take comes from Southern kitchens that swap the vinegar for buttermilk and use frozen unsweetened coconut. This variation is less sweet, with a fresh coconut flavor that’s subtle but satisfying. Try it if you enjoy desserts like vegan maple glazed roasted rhubarb—delicate, yet rich with depth.

Want to make it tropical? Stir in a spoonful of crushed pineapple or a pinch of lime zest. You can even replace the vanilla with almond extract for a deeper, nutty profile. Each change puts a new spin on the familiar comfort of this easy coconut pie.

How to store, freeze, and reheat leftovers

Once your pie is cooled, you can store it at room temperature for up to 3 days—if it doesn’t include dairy like milk or buttermilk. For versions with dairy, refrigerate and cover tightly with plastic wrap or foil. It stays fresh in the fridge for 4 to 5 days.

To freeze, wrap the whole pie or individual slices in a double layer of plastic wrap and foil. Store flat in the freezer for up to 3 months. When ready to enjoy, thaw overnight in the fridge, then let it come to room temperature. You can warm slices gently in a low oven if desired.

Much like rhubarb muffins with Greek yogurt, this pie retains its texture and flavor beautifully—even after freezing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

If you’re looking for a dessert that’s as nostalgic as it is indulgent, French coconut pie delivers on every level. From its crisp crust and golden crackle top to that rich, chewy custard center, this pie is simplicity at its finest. Whether you go classic, try a twist like drunken coconut pie, or want a dairy-free option, this recipe adapts beautifully. Serve it at room temperature or chilled, and you’ll have a slice that satisfies coconut lovers every time.

This pie brings back memories of family dinners and Southern charm, and now it’s your turn to bake those memories into your own kitchen.

Love recipes like this? Join me on Pinterest for fresh inspiration and follow along on Facebook for more cozy, everyday favorites I know you’ll love. Let’s cook something wonderful together!